Recently I started monitoring a Node.js app that we have been developing at work. After a while, I found that its memory usage % was growing slowly, like 20% in 3 days. The memory usage was measured in the following Node.js code.
const os = require("os"); const total = os.totalmem(); const free = os.freemem(); const usage = ((free - total) / total) * 100;
So, they are basically from OS, which was Alpine Linux on Docker in this case. Luckily I also had memory usages of application processes recorded, but they were not increasing. Then why is the OS memory usage increasing?
Buffers and Cached Memory
top command with
Shift+m (sort by memory usage) and compared processes on a long-running server and ones on a newly deployed server. Processes on each side were almost same. The only difference was that
cached Mem were high on the long-running one.
After some research, or googling, I concluded that it was not a problem. Most of
cached Mem are given up when application processes claim more memory.
free -m command provides a row for
free taking buffers and cached into consideration.
free -m total used free shared buffers cached Mem: 3950 285 3665 183 12 188 -/+ buffers/cache: 84 3866 Swap: 1896 0 1896
So, what are they actually? According to the manual of
/proc/meminfo, which is a pseudo file and the data source of
top and friends:
Buffers %lu Relatively temporary storage for raw disk blocks that shouldn't get tremendously large (20MB or so). Cached %lu In-memory cache for files read from the disk (the page cache). Doesn't include SwapCached.
I am still not sure what exactly
Buffers contains, but it contains metadata of files, etc. and it's relatively trivial in size.
Cached contains cached file contents, which are called page cache. OS keeps page cache while RAM has enough free space. That was why the memory usage was increasing even when processes were not leaking memory.
If you are interested, What is the difference between Buffers and Cached columns in /proc/meminfo output? on Quora has more details about
So, should we use
free + buffers + cached?
/proc/meminfo has an even better metric called
MemAvailable %lu (since Linux 3.14) An estimate of how much memory is available for starting new applications, without swapping.
cat /proc/meminfo MemTotal: 4045572 kB MemFree: 3753648 kB MemAvailable: 3684028 kB Buffers: 13048 kB Cached: 193336 kB ...
Its background is explained well in the commit in Linux Kernel, but essentially it excludes non-freeable page cache and includes reclaimable slab memory. The current implementation in Linux v4.12-rc2 still looks almost same.
Some implementation of
free -m have
available column. For example, on Boot2Docker:
free -m total used free shared buff/cache available Mem: 3950 59 3665 183 226 3597 Swap: 1896 0 1896
It is also available on AWS CloudWatch metrics via
Some background about Docker
My another question was "Are those metrics same in Docker?". Before diving into this question, let's check how docker works.
According to Docker Overview: The Underlying Technology, processes in a Docker container directly run in their host OS without any virtualization, but they are isolated from the host OS and other containers in effect thanks to these Linux kernel features:
- namespaces: Isolate PIDs, hostnames, user IDs, network accesses, IPC, etc.
- cgroups: Limit resource usage
- UnionFS: Isolate file system
Because of the namespaces,
ps command lists processes of Docker containers in addition to other processes in the host OS, while it cannot list processes of host OS or other containers in a docker container.
By default, Docker containers have no resource constraints. So, if you run one container in a host and don't limit resource usage of the container, and this is my case, the container's "free memory" is same as the host OS's "free memory".
Memory Metrics on Docker Container
If you want to monitor a Docker container's memory usage from outside of the container, it's easy. You can use
docker stats CONTAINER CPU % MEM USAGE / LIMIT MEM % NET I/O BLOCK I/O PIDS fc015f31d9d1 0.00% 220KiB / 3.858GiB 0.01% 1.3kB / 0B 0B / 0B 2
But if you want to get the memory usage in the container or get more detailed metrics, it gets complicated. Memory inside Linux containers describes the difficulties in details.
sysinfo, which is used by
os.freemem() of Node.js, are not isolated, you get metrics of host OS if you use normal utilities like
free in a Docker container.
To get metrics specific to your Docker container, you can check pseudo files in
/sys/fs/cgroup/memory/. They are not standardized according to Memory inside Linux containers though.
cat /sys/fs/cgroup/memory/memory.usage_in_bytes 303104 cat /sys/fs/cgroup/memory/memory.limit_in_bytes 9223372036854771712
memory.limit_in_bytes returns a very big number if there is no limit. In that case, you can find the host OS's total memory with
/proc/meminfo or commands that use it.
It was a longer journey than I initially thought. My takeaways are:
- Available Memory > Free Memory
MemAvailableif available (pun intended)
- Processes in a Docker container run directly in host OS
- Understand what you are measuring exactly, especially in a Docker container